Sheriff angered by videotaped beating of illegal immigrants

By The Associated Press
Arizona Daily Wildcat
April 4, 1996

RIVERSIDE, Calif. - Sheriff Larry Smith said he was shocked by a videotape of his deputies beating two suspected illegal immigrants after a car chase, saying they clearly used excessive force.

''There will be no cover-up,'' Smith said yesterday in his first comments on the beating taped by news helicopters overhead. ''No one is above the law.''

The FBI has opened a civil rights investigation, and both the Los Angeles and Riverside sheriff's departments are investigating. The clubbing happened in Los Angeles County but the pursuit began in Riverside County.

''We have to uphold the highest standards of conduct in this department,'' Smith said. ''Sadly, I didn't see these standards on the tape. It was clearly an excessive use of force.''

Deputies Tracy Watson and Kurtis Franklin both were suspended with pay. Franklin has been with the department for 20 years, Watson for five.

''The entire story has not yet been told,'' said Franklin's attorney, John Barnett, who also represented a police officer charged in the Rodney King beating case. ''This was a lawful use of force.''

Outside, about 75 people protested the beating.

''It's not an isolated incident,'' said Victoria Baca, president of the Mexican Political Association. ''The only difference this time is that the video cameras were rolling.''

The deputies clubbed the immigrants after chasing a battered pickup crammed with people suspected of sneaking across the border. TV news helicopters captured the beating on video in broad daylight.

During the chase, the pickup reached speeds of 100 mph, its shabby camper top disintegrating in the wind to reveal about 20 people crammed inside. The truck finally stopped on the side of the freeway and most of the passengers in back ran away.

One deputy, holding his baton two-handed like a baseball bat, was videotaped clubbing a man on the back and shoulders, even as the man fell, face down, on the ground. A woman got out of the cab and the same deputy beat her in the back with the baton, then grabbed her by the hair and pulled her to the ground. At least one other deputy struck her with his baton. Neither person, both Mexicans, appeared to resist or attempt to get away from the white officers.

Smith declined to comment on news reports that a sheriff's dispatcher had ordered the deputies to discontinue the chase but was ignored.

(OPINIONS) (SPORTS) (NEXT_STORY) (DAILY_WILDCAT) (NEXT_STORY) (POLICEBEAT) (COMICS)