Is UA's Writing Skills Improvement Program racist in nature? Or is it a necessary tool for disadvantaged students? According to its Web site, students are eligible for free tutoring through WSIP, " · if they are of an ethnic minority (American Indian, Asian or Pacific Islander, African American, or Hispanic), or if they are receiving any of the following categories of financial assistance: Federal Perkins Loans, Pell Grants, Supplemental Opportunity Grants, Stafford Loans and Work Study Assistance as well as State Student Incentive Grants." WSIP has recently amended its mission statement to allow students who do not meet this criteria to receive help on an individual basis if there is "space available" and "he/she has been referred by a professor." Regardless, some still contend that it is wrong for a state-funded program to be able to provide or deny its services based on race and ethnicity. Others say that programs such as these are vitally important and exist for the sole purpose of leveling past inequalities; that to not provide such a service would be discriminatory. The positive results are undeniable: "The average WSIP participant's semester English course grades before and after tutoring evidenced a difference of 1.37 grade points," the WSIP boasts on its Web site.
[Read article]