Arizona Daily Wildcat Online
Front Page
Go Wild
Live Culture
Police Beat
Special Sections
Photo Spreads
The Wildcat
Letter to the Editor
Wildcat Staff
Job Openings
Advertising Info
Student Media
Arizona Student Media Info
Student TV
Student Radio
The Desert Yearbook
Daily Wildcat Staff Alumni

Save your 'Rent' money for another movie

Photo courtesy of Sony Pictures
'Five hundred twenty five thousand six hundred minutes' is how long 'Rent' fans have waited for a movie of this acclaimed musical to come out. Now no one is eagerly awaiting the inevitable sequel, 'Rent 2: Eviction.'
By Tessa Strasser
Arizona Daily Wildcat
Thursday, December 1, 2005
Print this

"Rent" starts off panning over the eight cast members standing on a dusty wooden stage facing an empty auditorium belting out the hit theme song "Seasons of Love." Good omen? Sadly, no.

The idea of "Rent" as a movie is novel. It was bound to happen, giving Hollywood a chance to cash in on the award-winning Broadway musical by the same name.

"Rent" chronicles the story of seven friends living the bohemian life in New York. Mark (Anthony Rapp) is an aspiring filmmaker, Roger (Adam Pascal) is a sensitive guitarist who can't write any songs, Tom (Jesse L. Martin) is their third roommate, Angel (Wilson Jermaine Heredia) is the flamboyant drag queen who Tom falls for, Mimi (Rosario Dawson) is an exotic dancer who catches the eye of Roger, Maureen (Idina Menzel) is the drama queen who used to date Mark until she dumped him, and Joanne (Tracie Thoms) is the woman she dumped him for. They're struggling just to pay the rent for their apartments, while their former roommate Benny (Taye Diggs) is trying to shut the apartment complex down and jack up their rent in order to build a cyber studio.

At times, the movie gets a little too caught up in romantic elements. The filmmakers are so busy trying to pair the cast off and show the drama within each relationship, that they almost forget about the other plotline.

See It!

4 out of 10
135 min
Sony Pictures

"Rent" has the ability to make a strong social commentary on AIDS. Despite the fact that four of the members of the group of friends have it, however, it never seems to affect them that much. They may have AIDS, but there are no visible symptoms. The actors completely neglect this part of their character. By the time one of the characters dies from the disease, it's easy to forget that he even had it after all of the vibrant energy he exudes while prancing around the streets of New York.

The format of the movie allows for much more creative sets than the play. Obviously, it's no longer constricted to what can fit on one stage. The characters transition from their beloved run-down apartment to the big business part of the city to even a mountain range in Santa Fe, N.M. (which comes off like a bad Bon Jovi music video).

The problem from which the movie suffers is that it doesn't know how to transition well from the singing to the speaking parts. The actors come off awkwardly with their dialogue right before the singing, not knowing quite how to set it up. After a musical piece finishes, the cast always ends up ruining the climax the song creates and stumble getting back to the casual dialogue. The worst part is when the actors attempt to blend both together at one go. As a result, the movie becomes stiff.

This is not to say the acting is horrible, nor is the singing. They would be able to stand alone and make a quality film, but together they are a bad fit. Obviously, you can't take the music out of a musical, but the director should have at least attempted to make a better fit of the two.

Fans of the musical who have already seen it on Broadway will obviously want to check out the movie to see how it compares. To them, it will be like the Cliffs Notes version of the play, refreshing their memories of how good it was. To those not familiar with the play, don't see the movie just to cheat your way out of a trip to New York to catch the real thing. Stick with the soundtrack if you are craving that badly to hear "Seasons of Love." At least the soundtrack will be shorter.

Write a Letter to the Editor
Local group brings improv to the people
Tucson and campus calendar
Waiting for nothing
Learning the language of wine
Baumbach brings it all back home
Save your 'Rent' money for another movie
Theron has chance to 'Flux' muscles
Scatter Shots
Diverse dance show fun for everyone
Production unfolds life of legend Hank Williams
'Collisions' is inventive, at least when you can hear it
Ehrenreich tries on a white-collar in 'Bait and Switch'
Steve Carell chooses stapler as weapon of choice
Restaurant and Bar Guide
Housing Guide
Search for:
advanced search Archives


Webmaster -
Copyright 2005 - The Arizona Daily Wildcat - Arizona Student Media