Arizona Daily Wildcat
Monday, January 31, 2005
Print this
Free trade doesn't equal freedom
I was quite shocked to read the derisive Dec. 7 letter from Chad Mills condemning the protesters of the Andean Free Trade Conference. In his letter, Mr. Mills calls the protesters ignorant, says that Native Americans have never appreciated the wheel and goes on to claim that they are working toward slavery and savagery.
I'm not sure if Mr. Mills is attempting to establish himself as intolerant, or if he is trying to defend free trade. What he has done however is shown his own ignorance of the stance of peoples throughout the American continents, including a great number of us within the United States, against free trade agreements that do not favor them. Far from protesting "freedom," as Mills claims, they are seeking the freedom of autonomy that has been systematically denied to peoples throughout South America by capitalist interests from Europe and the United States. Mr. Mills, as do many conservatives that wish to blur the issues at stake with illogical defensive appeals, equivocates free trade with the capitalist system in general, which of course - in Mills' mind - is the same thing as freedom itself. However, free trade is not freedom itself. Only self-determination could truly be characterized as freedom and it is exactly this that these protesters wish to attain. This entails control over local markets for the people who actually live there. Contrary to Mr. Mills' explanation that they wish to hold on to primitive farming techniques thus shackling their own future, these peoples wish to simply control the means of their own survival and remain independent of foreign corporations that dominate their markets and profit from their resources. Is this too much to ask, and do we not all wish the same for ourselves?
Far from moving toward "slavery and savagery," as Mills suggests, these protesters are calling for freedom and a greater sophistication in trade policy from their governments.
Isaac Armour
philosophy senior
People didn't protest Clinton as much because he sought international opinion
This is in response to Brian Danker's letter, "Where were protests against Clinton?"
There were no protests against Clinton because the international community requested our help. This was not a mission undertaken by the United States without the consent of the United Nations. We heard the call to free the oppressed people of Bosnia, and we accepted it.
There was no call to go to war in Iraq. The Bush administration devised and executed their plan without the consent of the United Nations or even a moderate fraction of the international support we had during Bosnia.
Furthermore, Bush's reasons for the invasion of Iraq did not include the human rights violations that went on there. He lied to the American public, claiming that the CIA had definite evidence that Iraq had ties with Osama bin Laden (evidence that the CIA said never existed). He also claimed that Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction and posed a real threat to America.
As you can see, the situations are hardly comparable. Clinton didn't have to lie to anyone before attacking Bosnia. If Iraq had less oil and less personal motivation for Bush, then perhaps we'd see fewer protests.
Michael Werth
astrophysics sophomore
Letter saying there were no Bosnia protests confused
This letter is in response to Brian Danker's letter in Wednesday's Wildcat, in which he claimed that there were no protests during President Clinton's invasion of Bosnia. First of all, the United States never invaded Bosnia - we invaded Serbia. Second, there were heated protests against this war, including an impassioned denunciation of then Secretary of State Madeleine Albright's speech at UA graduation in 1999. Protesters stood behind Albright during her speech with a banner that read: "Clinton and Milosevic - Partners in War Crime." I was personally threatened with arrest that day.
As far as Mr. Danker's assertion that Republicans are busy earning paychecks, that's great. I just wish every person in the United States had an opportunity to work. However, remember that the Federal Reserve controls interest rates to, in part, prevent unemployment from getting too low. The belief is that low unemployment leads to inflation. So if unemployment is specifically engineered from above, what exactly are the unemployed to do?
Rachel Wilson
Second Year Law Student
Kidz Korner not perfect, but necessary
In response to the criticism concerning Kidz Korner, I would like to make just a few points. By no means is Kidz Korner a solution to the issues student parents are facing, but I as a student, parent, and president of BabyCats would like to think that Kidz Korner is simply a start in making the UA campus a little more child friendly. While I agree that both children and studies require undivided attention, we as parents know that we can use all the help we can get. If the opening of Kidz Korner allows me a chance to have my daughter on campus in a child friendly environment where I can hop on line, make a couple of quick notecards, participate in a group study session, or have a place to meet other parents and at the same time know that my child is in an area that she can enjoy, then I say thanks to the UA, the Dean of Students, the VP of Campus Life, the Commission on the Status of Women and Commuter Student Affairs. I look at the opening of Kidz Korner as an opportunity to prove to the university that there is a highly underserved population of students on campus working very hard to support the demands of balancing work, studies, and a family. Kidz Korner is a small start, and a nice one, but I know that BabyCats is out there hoping to advocate for more! Change starts out small and with effort, advocacy, and participation, big changes are possible. So all you parents on campus, get out there, use the space, and let the university know that we deserve more!
Anastasia Arab
physiology senior
Poor research into list of countries with terrorists
Jonathan Riches writes in recent column:
"There are violent Islamist groups in Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Somalia, Eritrea, Djibouti, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bosnia, Croatia, Albania, Algeria, Tunisia, Lebanon, the Philippines, Indonesia, Tajikistan, Azerbaijan, Chechnya, Uzbekistan and Kashmir (among many others)." He then goes on to say that people have died in each of these countries because of violent Islamic terrorist acts. While I can't speak for each country on the list, I have lived in Djibouti (one of the above mentioned countries) for 16 years and Mr. Riches' statements are completely false concerning Djibouti. There has never been a death due to violent Islamic terrorist attacks in Djibouti.
Unfortunately, Mr. Riches' column is fueled more by racist stereotype than reality.
Mike Brislen
From Djibouti
Croatia doesn't belong on list of terrorist nations
It's a very small country with 95% of Christian Population, about some 4.5 millions, so I am surprised to find it on the list which countries like Algeria or Chechnya. Likely within EU nations of Britain, Germany and France, or the Netherlands there are 100 times more radical Islamist than in Croatia (if there are any there at all). Croatia won its war on terror in 1996 (After Rijeka bombing), sadly in fact her late president Tudjman tried to warn US diplomats at the conference held in Sarajevo (1999) bout growing danger of Islamic terrorism. Now-a-days Croatian special force is serving with distinction in Afghanistan. So could you post me a link to your news source bout Croatia having any violent Islamic groups?
Zlatko Tkalcevic
Croatian
If there's terrorists in Azerbaijan, it's news to us
I read with interest a column on the dangers of global terrorism in the Wildcat.
It mentioned a number of countries - including Azerbaijan where I am based as a correspondent for Agence France Presse - where there are dangerous Islamist groups.
I was hoping the author might be able to point me in the right direction about how to find them here because it would be great to blow the cover on their activities.
Simon Ostrovsky
Azerbaijanian LS M.Z.
A tribute to Dr. Herman R. Lucero Phd for his recent acheivement
Thank you Doctor Lucero for being our Teacher.
Doctor Herman (Sonny) Lucero
God s child
Son of Herman & Frances Lucero
Descendant of your ancestors
Brother
Relative
Friend
Student
Employee
Military Veteran
Husband
Father
Grandfather
Mentor
Educator
Retiree
University of Arizona-Tucson Doctorate Degree Graduate
Humble beginning
Listening
Feeling
Tasting
Smelling
Seeing
In doing so, you learned from all of your life s teachers
Seeking knowledge
Questioning
Praying
Learning right from wrong
Praising right
Condemning wrong
Winning
Losing
Counseling
Teaching
Sonny, I commend you for the lifes journey you had chosen.
You have personified one of lifes challenges;
Setting goals and achieving them;
Being our inspiration and Teacher.
On the 18th of December 2004 You had achieved what is considered The Epitome of Academics: Graduated with the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Language, Reading & Culture. With pride and admiration for what you have achieved and within my mind and soul, for becoming, as God intended, the Quintessence of Humanity your name and achievement, Doctor Herman (Sonny) Lucero, PHD will forever be shared and remembered with Admiration, Respect & Love Donald Arias Cousin In relation to your article on Monday 24th January, 2005
Your views seem strange and somewhat extreme.
Just wondering how you came to form them? You seem to be under the impression that Islam is to blame for attacks by Al Qaeda et al against the US. Are you views typical of young Americans? It is true that Al Qaeda want to spread Islam throughout the world using violence (their argument is that the use of violence will shock people into becoming true Muslims as they see what happens when they fail to be true Muslims), but surely George Bush is merely doing the same? Wishing to spread 'democracy' and his Christianity through the use of violence. Is there a really difference between what the two are doing? Secondly, it is unfair not to apportion at least some blame for Al Qaeda on 'the West', who brought the Islamic world the Crusades. And from that to British, French, Spanish, Belgian, Dutch, Russian, Portuguese, American, Italian, etc. occupation of Muslim territories, it can't be said the west has a gleaming record with regard to its treatment of Muslims. The western, Christian world has made itself a very easy target for religious extremists, and with the poverty of many Muslim nations as it is, they provide ideal breeding grounds for fighters. Terrorism cannot be defeated through force. You can only fight the causes of terrorism. A guerrilla army cannot be defeated, to try is futile. How did the IRA come to end its campaign of violence? Through an offer of a political process that would improve the lives its supporters. Once this was on offer, support for violence fell. Using violence against Al Qaeda will only strengthen it, gain it more members, more money. Violence only breeds violence. Just look at Ireland, it's been going on here for over 800 years. Hopefully we've finally learnt this lesson. It's terrifying to think that the USA hasn't.
Brendan Carroll
first year politics student at Queen's University, Belfast, Ireland.
Descriptions of liberals don't fit statistics
In your letter you seem to incinuate that liberals are lazy, welfare recipients and conservatives are hard-working and financially accomplished. It's interesting that 17 of the 20 states (85%) in this country who receive the most federal spending per dollar of federal taxes paid are Red States. In comparison, 11 of the 14 (79%) of the states receiving the least federal spending per dollar of federal taxes paid are Blue States. One could conclude that your argument is not only logically flawed, but factually incorrect as well. By far, the citizens of Blue States earn bigger "paychecks" than those of Red States, which is the reason that the powerful economies of the Blue States support the underperforming and lackluster economies of Red States.
In addition, the working class are the ones who are fighting and dying in your wars. If I were you, I might be more careful not to belittle them.
Tariq Rahman
Political science junior
Women's Plaza Won't Bring Equality
While it may seem honorable to name buildings after human rights leaders and dedicate plazas to different groups in society, it doesn't serve the purpose of bringing equality and non-discrimination. Recently, UA renamed the Economics building to the Cesar E. Chavez building and now UA is considering a women's plaza. Similar to seatbelts on airplanes, these serve to make people feel better but don't really make much of a difference. Perhaps UA donors should spend the money instead on a workshop to educate people about different cultures and groups. I hope that in the future more time and money will be spent working to bring equality instead of just giving the public a security blanket.
Eric Austin
Engineering Physics Sophomore
Andy Ganoa's letter regarding Immigration
Andy Ganoa's letter regarding immigration represents the current liberal response to anyone who disagrees with an open-border position - they label their opponents racist. Mr. Ganoa's letter, while filled with plenty of entertaining "klan" rhetoric, failed to address the hundreds of millions of dollars spent providing emergency medical care, education, and other public services to illegal immigrants every year. Additionally, Mr. Ganoa's knee-jerk response fails to account for the numerous legal immigrants who do not believe that illegals ought to be granted a free pass into our country. I wonder if Mr. Ganoa would be so quick to label these immigrants "racist" as well.
Mike Yates
3rd Year Law StudentMichael.yates@law.arizona.edu
In response to Mr. Kunzelmann's letter
This letter is in response to Mr. Kunzelmann's letter on immigration. I must say it seems Mr. Kunzelmann never attended an American History Class or a Biology class in his life. First he says "..a topic that happens to concern members of another race." What race is that? Last time I checked there is only the HUMAN race which is divided into ETHNICITIES. He moves on to claim that his European ancestors tried to act "American" and that they didn't impose their culture on others. Well, before his ancestors came from jolly ol' England, Germany, Italy and Poland; my ancestors from Spain were already here and had populated what is today the southwest and Florida. His ancestors did not impose their culture on others,they simply irradicated the Native tribes and what was left of them, they rounded them up in reservations. Plus how could they act "American" when they were the ones who defined what "American" is: Puritan, Protestant and the Work Ethic. But today it seems acting American is gorging on McDonald's while performing celebrity worship. I do agree with Mr. Kunzelmann that celebrating Cinco de Mayo is ridiculous because it is nothing but a Beer Holiday, but I would be ashamed to claim that American Culture is about the Super Bowl when there is a lot of rich, even if brief, history in this country.
Angel Del Valle
Religious Studies/sophomore
Inappropriate to ask immigrants to act American
I'm upset by a letter asking immigrants to act American! America is a melting pot and will always be a nation of immigrants. As I wrote in a previous letter, when I took an oath to become an American, I was sitting next to countless Mexicans, two retired Germans on one side and an Israeli girl on the other side. There were people from Albania to Zimbabwe. Each and everyone has their own set of culture and values. We all stood up and proudly rose our right hand to become American. It was probably one of the most important days of my life. But becoming American does not mean I forget my values, my identity and become blind to my companions who take an oath with. The fact that a Muslim guy and a Jewish girl can stand by side by side and embrace a new nationality is an American experience!
I take pride in the fact that I had the chance to embrace Mexican culture in Arizona, have Jewish friends at UofA, and of course enjoying the game of American Football. At the same time, I was happy to share my Indian culture, my Islamic faith, and play Football (ahem Soccer to some) with friends.
I still have a lot to learn from the real Americanos:
the Apaches, the Cherokee, the Navajos, and the Zunis. Their appreciation of the environment and spiritual connection with nature give meaning to Earth Day!
I celebrate all Gringo Holidays, probably one of the few brown people celebrating St. Paddies day at O'Malleys, attedning Yaqui easter festival, say oohh and ahhh during the fireworks on 4th of July, have Seder dinners and of course love those dances Cinco de Mayo. But of all the Mexican holidays, but I really enjoy celebrating The Birthday of President Benito Juárez -- March 21st:The "GEORGE WASHINGTON" of Mexico! I wonder why many Mexican Americans forget to celebrate such an auspicious day!
President Juárez is not only a national hero of Mexico, but for all those people who share the views of freedom and liberty. Freedom and Liberty are American values!
By the way, many Mexican Americans and Mexican immigrants have volunteered to serve our forces. They have sacrificed their lives for freedom and liberty here at home as well as in Iraq and Afghanistan. Kunzelmann, you wanna make them act American? America is in their hearts (as well as President Juárez)!
To better understand another culture you must travel. If you cannot travel, visit a local event or a restaurant totally different than yours! Trying to understand others is a unique experience. Sharing yourself with others is so American!
Ahmad Saad Nasim
Former ASUA senator
Taking issue with Tim Christiansen's letter of 1/27
I take issue with Tim Christiansen's letter of 1/27, as it is the best example of a Strawman fallacy that the Wildcat has printed this semester. Brian Danker never said that we provoked the war in Bosnia, nor that it was not just; but rather that it was not protested by the same people protesting the current war in Iraq. What Congress did is beside the point; Mr. Danker was speaking about those currently protesting the Iraqi War. Further, Prof. Christiansen suggests that this war should not have been fought, and in doing so belies the ugly side of liberalism: liberals are against the spread of freedom and democracy to Muslim nations. There are a host of reasons as to why this is the case, one of which is because they fear that if people are free to choose their religion they might become Christians, which is anathema to the liberal cause. I should expect better from a professor at the U of A, but we are a liberal school, which means that we value towing the politically-correct line before academic quality.
Silas Montgomery
Judaic Studies Senior
KidzKorner a safe, clean environment
This is in response to the criticism Lisa Barnes stated concerning the new Kidz Korner in the student commuter lounge. I have deep gratitude and appreciation to U of A, the Dean of Students, the VP of Campus Life, the Commission on the Status of Women and Commuter Student Affairs for offering this safe clean environment for my child to play while I am in class. The Kidz Korner allows my husband to leave his position on campus for one hour a day to watch our small daughter, TJ, while I am in class, which would not be possible as other child friendly places on campus are not available. This is a great help to the parents attending UofA where they can effectively deal with the logistics of juggling children while getting an education. The Kidz Korner has lifted a huge burden off of my shoulders to be able to have my child, safely attended, while I'm on campus, in a place I feel that is safe and secure. Prior to the lounge opening I would have had to be separated for many hours from my child as I commuted to and from home to attend my classes. I now utilize the lounge to do homework and to care for my child between classes and have benefited greatly from this service. I encourage UofA to do all that they can to help parents continue to advance their education.
Cynthea Carter
computer engineering undergraduate
Public needs to be aware of HPV
I came across this article in my vast search for knowledge on HPV. My mother recently found out that she is in deep water with this virus. I must admit that I'm terrified to lose her and would like to learn how I can help her get through these hard times. I guess that my main goal is to also warn and tell people that this virus tears apart families just like any other problem and it has slowly torn apart mine. Thanks for the info.
Jessica Hernandez
High school student
Kidz Korner important for student parents
In response to Lisa Barnes letter "Kidz Korner not helping parents." I whole-heartedly agree with her that it is nearly impossible to get serious studying done while properly taking care of a child. However, in response to your question, Kidz Korner is helping parents by: acknowledging our existence as student-parents and our importance as valued community members, providing a meeting place for parent networks (BabyCats meet there every other week), and providing a safe place to eat lunch between running errands. Kidz Korner has created an awareness of our existence and our unique issues as well as fostering open dialogue to raise awareness. In other words, this is an important first step to prove to the administration that the thousands of us who are attempting to juggle school, work and family can not forsake one for the other. I vote for a parent-resource center or perhaps a drop-in childcare center. I would love to be able to use the Rec Center once in awhile, too. We need more, but the university is using this as a test of how much they should give us. Read the entire paper published by the Commission on the Status of Women on our website: http://clubs.asua.arizona.edu/~babycats Join our BabyCats and BabyCats Too network. Write your ASUA or GPSC representative. Thank you, Lisa, for creating dialogue.
Diane Sotelo
President, BabyCats Too
Write a Letter to the Editor